ShdwProductions's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Clay Earth]

Nice

Nice animation:

Animation; 10 / 10
Audio; 8 / 10
Content; 8 / 10

I must say that it was nice to find an animation that was not created on flash or after effects! Stop motion is certainly a difficult animation style but I must say you did an excellent job. The audio was okay, it did not intrude on the animation but served as a nice background for the animation itself. The content was a bit strange, but as this was a test I think that it was great. Very well done!

All in all; 9 / 10

[Enjoy Your Heaven]

Absolutely Brilliant!

Sweet!

Animation; 10 / 10
Audio; 10 / 10
Content; 10 / 10

Seriously good animation, each movement of the characters was smooth and the transitions from scene to scene was expertly done. The audio was completely clear and the music was well placed. The content was very funny, the idea behind it solid and original in my opinion. It really appealed to my sense of humour! Also, it was nice to see a Play / Pause button on thejavascript:submission_controller.G etReviewController().SaveReview(); animation. Something that very few animators include.

All in all; 10 / 10

curtiSmith responds:

Thanks, yeah the film is a bit longer than a lot of stuff on newgrounds so I thought it'd be handy to be able to skip and pause. I'm glad you liked it :D

[magic mustache]

Cheered me the hell up!

Thank you soooo much! You actually cheered me up to no end!

Animation; 10 / 10
Audio; 10 / 10
Content; 10 / 10

Very, very good! Right, well the animation was brilliant, it was very smooth, extremely smooth in fact! Also the artwork behind each character was brilliant! The audio was supremely good, the voices were clear, the script writing for this was amazing! As for the content, well, I just found it funny, there was no swearing, which is a relief, considering the way that some people swear to get laughs. This humour was simple but, just, plain, funny! The script I must say again was amazing, the interaction between the characters was perfect! Well done! Keep up the good work!

All in all; 10 / 10

[A Rainy Day]

Ah! Rain!

Okay here is my review, enjoy!

Animation; 8 / 10
Audio; 7 / 10
Content; 9 / 10

I must say that the animation was not too bad, it was a little choppy in places, but it was not bad. the artwork for the animation was certainly good. The audio was okay, the sound effects were certainly fine, however I would have like to have heard some more music, but again the selective use of music was not too bad. Content was good, I even considered doing something like this myself. The idea is fairly original, and if it helps I know what it is like to have your computer crash, I nearly lost an entire novel once.

All in all; 8 / 10

[N vs E]

Good

Nice to see a smooth fighting animation:

Animation; 10 / 10
Audio; 9 / 10
Content; 8 / 10

Righty, the animtion itself was very smooth, absolutly not problems to find there, you obviously know what you are doing. The audio was very good, all of the sound effects were properly synced up as well, I think that the music was okay, although I would liked to have seen more animation with more music. This brings me to the content, I personally think that it was a bit short, although with the number of frames you spent making it, this merely me being picky. Also, it would have been nice to have some sort of back story, maybe a reason why he is fighting? I know that there was the mention of clones, but I still think that there could be more. Just a thought...

All in all; 9 / 10

neem2345 responds:

thanks a lot man....perfect review.....

[Super Ninja Chicken]

Chicken?

Right...

Animation; 5 / 10
Audio; 2 / 10
Content; 3 / 10

Okay, first off, I must say this is not the worst animation that I have seen today...seriously. The animtion was not to bad even if it was a bit simple. The lip syncing was fairly good. The audio was terrible. It was too loud for the microphone that you were using making it tinny and not good at all. I advise you to spend money on a good microphone, or get some audio software to sort out the sound instead. The content was, well, a bit odd but not terrible. I get the feeling that you have seen this sort of gag in other animations or on films and have tried to do it yourself. (please note this is not a bad thing!) however, maybe you should go for some more orginal stuff instead.

All in all; 3 / 10

[When sad do the following]

Short, but not bad!

Well, I must say thank you, seriously today the only animations that I have reviewed have been bad!

Animation; 9 / 10
Audio; 8 / 10
Content; 9 / 10

Well done! You have managed to cheer me up! Okay, the animation was very good, the character was well drawn and the movements were all very smooth. Audio was not to bad either and fitted well with the content. As for the content it was quite short but the message was quite good, there was a bit of story to it, but it was pretty good no matter the length of animation.

All in all; 9 / 10

DunderAxel responds:

Ah, I thank you!

[Spacetrip]

Is this it?

No seriously, is this all the animation? MrNumbers you want a serious reply? Well here goes nothing!

Animation; 0 / 10
Audio; 0 / 10
Content; 0 / 10

Right, well this has to be the worst review I have given so far. That's suggesting of course that I can go below 0. Okay, animation, there was none, nothing, you just took a pitcure which you probably didn't make and used alpha and different colours to make it look pretty. Audio, again you probably didn't make it, but still all you did was import it into the animation. Content, well, need I say more?

All in all; 0 / 10

Steff responds:

Some people don't understand that I don't give a shit on reviews like these.

27.05.17 Edit: nobody still gives a shit about your review.

27.03.19 Edit: still nothing, sorry

[The Neon Forest]

Right...

This is my review of you animtion:

Animation; 4 /10
Audio; 5 / 10
Content; 2 / 10

Okay, the animation was not brilliant, however the artwork, particularly the trees was not bad at all. The animation was fairly smooth but there was not enough, there are many animators that have loops, take Weebl for example. But there was not enough here. Audio was not great, again if there was more I would give more of a mark however there was not enough audio to listen to. There was little content as well, nothing really to make this animation stand out from others. Try making a longer animation, it does not have to be half an hour long, maybe start with a story board, do the animation for it and then add the music.

All in all; 3 / 10

[Dental Appointment]

Your from England? Yay! Me too!

Hay! You're from England like me, that explains the humour then! Well here's my review:

Animation; 10 / 10
Audio; 10 / 10
Content; 10 / 10

Okay...lets see. Right the animtion was completely solid, very good character design and the scenes and setting were awesome. The audio was very clear, I understood every word and the music and sound effects didn't detract from the animation at all. Also the lip syncing was brilliant! Very well done on that. As for the content, well, the humour was just what I enjoy; funny, strange and just bloody weird! Well done for the whole animation!

All in all; 10 / 10